|
Think foreign education and chances are that you're thinking
of the US. Choosing the right college destination has become
confusing as ever. Here are some of the key differences between
studying the in the US and UK.
"I have been researching the courses offered at universities
for a long time now. I had to make a decision between universities
in the UK and US and finally, after a year of deliberation,
I have decided to go ahead with City University, London,"
says Soham Sheth, a B-school aspirant. Why did Soham decide
to opt for the UK? One of the main reasons why Soham opted
for the UK was because of his academic profile. With a GMAT
score of around 600, work experience of three to five years
and a three-year Bachelor's degree, he stood a good chance
of admission in City University London (Cass Business School),
one of the top ten UK business schools. However, this very
profile would not have qualified Sheth for admission to any
top ten B-school in the United States. UK universities tend
to receive a smaller number of applicants from India as compared
to US B-schools and are in comparison less competitive. Hence,
many students prefer applying to UK B-schools as compared
to American or Canadian business schools.
Another important reason why students prefer studying in the
UK is the duration of the academic course. Most master's degrees
in England can be completed in one year. Therefore, students
opting to study in the UK, save both time and money (an exception
to this rule is the London Business School, which offers a
two-year MBA program). However, do all students and parents
view this shorter duration as an advantage? "I tend to
be suspicious of schools that claim they can teach you everything
you need to know about a specific field in just one year,"
says Deepak Mathur, a prospective student's parent. David
Standen, ex-Director of Admissions of a leading business school
refutes the above argument saying, "No business person
I know would do a two-year MBA. Two-year MBAs are for potential
business people, but actual business people know the value
of their time."
Agrees Anurag Saxena, a University of Edinburgh alumnus, "Well,
the basic reason for me to consider the UK as compared to
the US was for its one-year MBA curriculum. However, the fundamental
differences between universities in the US and the UK made
it difficult for me to find direct parameters of comparison
between universities in both countries. For eg, the average
experience (and hence, age) for an MBA in the UK is likely
to be more. While US schools heavily depend upon GMAT scores,
schools in the UK lean towards taking a more a holistic view.
Ideally, it made sense to pursue an MBA after an optimum amount
of work experience because I was able to evaluate the leadership
skills I possess with those that I was lacking. However, the
fact that most MBAs in the UK are taught in one year made
the program extremely challenging. The curriculum kept us
engaged and teaches us effective time-management skills. We
were exposed to an invigorating learning environment where
everyone strived hard to achieve optimum results in the least
time. It challenged me intellectually and showed me a brand
new way of looking at the world around me, allowing me to
experiment with new ideas."
As per application requirements, students applying for business
courses appear for the GMAT. However to study in the UK, students
do not have to fulfill a GMAT requirement and this makes Indian
students suspicious as to why a school does not have a high
GMAT requirement.
British universities believe that they do not need to evaluate
GMAT scores because the GMAT does not test the parameters
that interest their admission officers the most. Their philosophy
is that standardized testing tries to fit everyone into the
same mould, whereas they are more interested in individuals.
Therefore, while students admitted to UK business schools
tend to be more mature and have more work experience than
their counterparts in other parts of the world, they also
tend to have lower GMAT scores. "Our job is to produce
rounded and knowledgeable citizens for the 21st century, not
to process stereotypes, "says Prof Hopwood, Dean, Said
Business School.
While some MBA and business students prefer the UK as their
favored destination, undergraduate students generally prefer
studying in a US university; primarily due to the course flexibility
available. In the US, undergraduate students can choose the
classes included in their academic curriculum and even design
their own major.
However, in the UK, the choices available to students are
restricted- if a student decides to change his/ her course
of study after one year, in all likelihood they would have
to repeat the year, whereas in the US, students have two years
to determine their major.
Besides, in order to study in the UK, students have to apply
using a UCAS form, which allows them to apply to only six
universities, while there are no restrictions to the number
of colleges one can apply to in the US.
One of the most important reasons Indian students have traditionally
applied to UK universities has been because universities in
the US required applicants to have an equivalent of a four-
year bachelor's degree, whereas UK universities accepted applicants
with a three-year bachelor's degree.
As a result, students would complete a one-year Master's degree
in the UK and then move on to a second master's degree in
the US or Canada. However, with the US relaxing rules on the
16th year requirement, students can now apply to a university
in the UK because they prefer the academic program and not
just to complete a requirement.
The available career opportunities are by far is the most
important factor for applicants to determine which country
they wish to study in. In the recent past, the British government
has made working in the UK easier for foreign nationals. Therefore,
international students are now eligible for various work permits
and should not disregard the UK because of the belief that
getting a job upon graduation will be impossible.
Furthermore, obtaining the US visa was often viewed as an
impossible feat due to which many students applied to the
UK as a backup. In sharp contrast, the UK visa was viewed
as an easier alternative to the US or for that matter, any
other country's visa.
However, with the US student visa now becoming relatively
easy to obtain, students should stop applying to the UK with
the sole purpose of a backup. Instead, one should apply to
the UK only if one is serious about courses and universities,
and not just because dad said that getting a US visa is difficult.
Students have a plethora of opportunities open to them and
the only way they can decide where to go is by making a thorough
assessment of their career goals. In that manner they will
choose the right program, at the right university, and in
the right country.
|